The debate between dry-type and oil-filled transformers is one of the most common in the electrical industry. If you're unsure which option best suits your needs, this comprehensive guide is here to help.
Transformers play a crucial role in modern power systems by modifying voltage levels—either stepping it down for low-power applications or stepping it up for long-distance transmission. As their usage grows, understanding the distinctions between different transformer types becomes increasingly important.
In this article, we’ll compare dry-type and oil-filled transformers across key factors such as cost, maintenance, noise, and energy efficiency. Read on to find out which solution is right for you.
A dry-type transformer is a stationary electrical device that utilizes environmentally friendly insulation systems and does not rely on liquid for cooling. Often referred to as "cast resin transformers," these units are designed for safe and reliable indoor use.
Housed in a ventilated enclosure, dry-type transformers rely on air circulation for cooling, with heat dissipated naturally through the surrounding air. Their windings—typically made of varnished copper or aluminum—are insulated with resin to protect against moisture and contaminants. Due to the limitations of air cooling, dry-type transformers are generally used in applications with voltage levels up to 35kV.
The global demand for dry-type transformers is projected to grow at a CAGR of 6.1% from 2020 to 2027, driven by continuous advancements in design and technology. Several types of dry-type transformers are available on the market, each suited to specific applications:
- Vacuum Pressure Impregnated (VPI) Transformers
- Vacuum Pressure Encapsulated (VPE) Transformers
- Open Wound Transformers
- Cast Coil Transformers
These transformers are widely used across commercial, industrial, and utility sectors. They are particularly common in low to medium-voltage applications, where they serve as reliable components in various types of electrical equipment.
Oil-filled, or oil-immersed, transformers are voltage conversion devices that rely on insulating oil for cooling and insulation. These transformers are housed in sealed, welded steel tanks filled with oil, which serves to transfer heat away from the windings and core.
During operation, heat generated by the transformer’s core and windings is absorbed by the insulating oil and then dissipated through radiators or other cooling mechanisms. Due to the flammability of the oil, these transformers are typically installed outdoors, where ventilation and safety can be more easily managed.
The oil-filled transformer market exceeded $28.3 billion in 2020 and is projected to grow at a CAGR of approximately 3.5% between 2021 and 2027. The two primary types are:
- Single-Phase Transformers
- Three-Phase Transformers
Oil-filled transformers are versatile and can be installed at ground level, on pads, or on utility poles. They are widely used in power transmission and distribution systems, renewable energy installations, and small commercial operations.
Understanding the differences between dry-type and oil-filled transformers is essential when selecting the right option for your application. Below are the key distinctions:
Transformers generate heat during operation and require an effective cooling system to prevent overheating and potential hazards.
- Oil-filled transformers use insulating oil to dissipate heat efficiently.
- Dry-type transformers rely on air or forced ventilation, which limits their cooling capacity.
- Oil-filled transformers require regular oil testing for chemical contamination and annual oil filtration, making them more maintenance-intensive.
- Dry-type transformers are more resistant to environmental conditions and require minimal maintenance. They can often remain connected to the grid even after minor incidents.
Contrary to common belief,
- Oil-filled transformers generally have lower operational costs due to higher energy efficiency and longer service life.
- Dry-type transformers consume more energy and may lead to higher long-term operating expenses.
- Oil-filled transformers offer easier and more effective recycling of the core and oil.
- Dry-type transformers have limited coil recyclability at the end of their lifespan.
- Oil-filled transformers are typically more efficient, offering better performance in high-load or high-voltage applications.
- Dry-type transformers are larger and less efficient, with a greater tendency to overheat during overload, which increases energy losses and maintenance needs.
This is one of the most critical differences.
- Oil-filled transformers are usually installed outdoors due to the risk of oil leaks and fire hazards.
- Dry-type transformers are safer and environmentally friendly, making them ideal for indoor use in spaces such as commercial buildings, hospitals, shopping malls, and office complexes.
In summary, oil-filled transformers generally offer advantages in terms of energy efficiency, lower operational costs, and better recyclability, making them a strong choice for outdoor and high-load applications. Dry-type transformers, while less efficient, are safer and more suitable for indoor environments where fire safety and reduced maintenance are priorities. The best option ultimately depends on your specific application needs and installation conditions.
Tianya Electric Co., Ltd. Makes Spectacular Debut at Uzbekistan International Exhibition
Tashkent, Uzbekistan, May 16, 2025 – Tianya Electric Co., Ltd. showcased new equipment technologies and innovative products, deepening Sino-Uzbek regional cooperation and exploring fresh development opportunities.
May. 19, 2025
Iron Core Transformers – Key Components, Applications, And More
The primary winding initiates electromagnetic induction by generating a magnetic field when AC flows through it. Its number of turns directly affects the voltage and current transferred to the secondary winding.
May. 15, 2025
